Under promise over deliver I think they have finally learned to guide very conservatively, so they can start to beat consensus estimates more consistently. We have seen successful companies do this quarter after quarter. We will see if this transformation from just a mining company to a battery producer will work. I think this company will ultimately be acquired unless they start being seen as destined toward bankruptcy. Then the bk vultures will pick up the assets at big discounts. I want clarity on the low production. Why was production only approximately 650 tons in April? At this point we will need V prices to increase into the second half of the year. The fact that they didn't mention Ansaldo is concerning. As well. To describe this company as disappointing is a massive understatement.