We continue to assume that Tata (500470-BO) will take up its option of the
KeMag and LabMag projects, leaving 20% of the project for New Millennium
(NML-SP) shareholders after a definitive agreement is signed. We currently
model NML financing its required capex using a series of dilutive equity issues in
the $4.80/share-$5.00/share range for these larger projects. Should the deal
allow NML to retain more of the project, there would be upside to our target.
Retaining 30% of the projects would increase our NAV to $5.60/share. We
assume 100% of the required capex is funded through equity, slightly offsetting
the increase in value to NML on a per share basis.
The key driver for our valuation rational is related to free cash flow coming out
of the nearer-term DSO project. NML has already partnered with Tata to
construct the DSO project and we have confidence in the time to cash flow.
Using this project as the engine to drive growth for NML, we see limited cash
available for redeploying into the much higher capex taconite projects. We
estimate NML will see $200MM of free cash emerge from the DSO operations
over the next three years; this is less than one year of the expected spend on
the $4.4B KeMag project at a 20% project interest. Assuming this cash is
redeployed into the taconite projects and an equity issue, backstopped by the
valuation of the DSO assets, we believe NML has a realistic opportunity to fund
~20% of the first taconite project on its own. We believe this approach is the
most likely scenario and have seen other deals struck in the space at similar
valuation levels. The retained percentage is open to variation but we believe an
effective ownership of above 25% may be too much for NML to fund internally
and would create a large equity issue overhang. Twenty-five percent ownership
of the first taconite project will require NML to fund $1.1B, relative to its current
market capitalization of $592MM; we view this as a stretch.
With limited cash flow and a modest balance sheet, we believe it is unrealistic
that NML will be able to go it alone. Current shareholders will own less of the
taconite projects once fully funded versus today either through a joint venture
relationship or through a massive equity issue; dilution is a forgone conclusion.
In addition, both taconite projects are also susceptible to capex creep, which has
started to re-emerge in various global mining projects.