GREY:PCCRF - Post by User
Comment by
elgin1on Dec 17, 2011 6:37pm
241 Views
Post# 19332229
RE: This is the time to buy...
RE: This is the time to buy...Curis downgraded by National Bank analyst :
Title: Curis Resources Ltd. - CUV (T) Cdn
.95 Price: Cdn
.95 StockRating: Outperform TargetPrice: Cdn$2.55 Headline: Florence Slowed by Re-Zoning Delays – Recalibrating Timeline & Risk
December 14, 2011 The NBF Daily Bulletin
Base Metals
Curis Resources Ltd.
CUV (T) Cdn
.95
Stock Rating: Outperform
(Unchanged)
Target: Cdn$2.55
(Was $5.15)
Risk Rating: Speculative
Reducing NAV Estimate, Target
Florence Slowed by Re-Zoning Delays –
Recalibrating Timeline & Risk Assumptions
(Unchanged)
? State and federal permitting largely on track, with onlymodest slippage in the timelines… Project work continueswith numerous permits already in place from prior work
conducted by BHP/Magma; permit amendments for the two
key permits (UIC and APP) to be issued by the ADEQ (State)
and EPA (Fed) are in process with receipt expected in late
Q1/12 or early Q2/12 (vs. Q4/11 previously).
? …however, ~1/2 of the resource resides on private landthat needs to be re-zoned for industrial use by Town
Council. This process is advancing more slowly and withwhat appears to be mounting opposition. Curis has prudently
pulled its re-zoning application and plans to re-submit post
receipt of permits. Approval by State/Fed authorities should
remove the onus on council to perform a technical review.
While this should facilitate re-zoning efforts, increased public
relations and perhaps time is needed to alter sentiment.
? NAV cut on more conservative timing and financingassumptions. To account for modest re-zoning delays andthe potential for additional field testing and monitoring before
full-scale permits are received, we are delaying commercial
production to H1/15 (H1/14 old). As well, we are upping the
project discount rate to 10% (8% old). We would look to revert
back to 8% on a positive re-zoning decision.
? Lowering target price to $2.55 from $5.15; Outperformrating maintained. Our target is based on a 0.65x multiple(0.75x old) of our fully diluted, fully financed NAV10% (NAV8%
old) estimate of $3.91/share ($6.78/sh old).
Company Profile: Stock Performance
Curis Resources Ltd. is a Canadian-listed development
company focused on advancing the 100%-owned Florence
oxide copper deposit in Arizona, USA.
Page 2
Investment Summary and Outlook
Curis Resources Ltd.’s principal asset, the 100%-owned Florence copper project,
affords investors exposure to a uniquely compelling, 3+ billion pound
development-stage asset in the United States. Florence is an advanced stage oxidecopper project located in central Arizona approximately 65 miles southeast of Phoenix and
70 miles north-northwest of Tucson. Florence is a shallowly buried, heavily fragmented,
porphyry copper deposit that is amenable to in-situ copper recovery. We characterize the
asset as uniquely compelling on the basis that Florence’s in-situ leach production plan
should benefit from both low capex and low operating cost intensity production. This is
juxtaposed to an industry that has been facing significantly escalating input cost pressures
and tight labour and equipment markets.
Lowering target price to $2.55 from $5.15; maintaining Outperform rating. While wecontinue to favour the technical merits of the project and Curis’ State and Federal-level
permitting efforts are tracking well, re-zoning efforts for the part of the deposit that lies on
private lands within the town of Florence have been met with increased opposition. In this
report we focus on the latter and recalibrate our company valuation taking into account
increased timing risk and more conservative financing assumptions. The net result is a
substantial drop in both our company valuation and target. Our target is based on a 0.65x
multiple (0.75x old) of our fully diluted, fully financed NAV10% (NAV8% old) estimate of$3.91/share ($6.78/sh old). We note, however, that a number of favourable catalysts are in
the lined up for H1/2012 that could cause us to revisit our assumptions with an upward bias.
Revising Project Assumptions in Response to Local Area
Developments
State and federal permitting largely on track, with only modest slippage in the
timelines… Project work continues with numerous permits already in place from prior workconducted by BHP and Magma. Permit amendments for the two key permits, the Aquifer
Protection Permit (APP) and the Underground Injection Certificate (UIC), are tracking well,
with receipt expected in late Q1/12 or early Q2/12, an approximate 3 month delay. The APP
and UIC are administered by the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) and
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), respectively.
…however, ~1/2 of the resource resides on private land that needs to be re-zoned for
industrial and opposition appears to be growing in this regard. While Town Council hasyet to make a final decision on re-zoning, minutes from recent Council meetings and media
reports suggest to us that more time, a revamped public relations campaign, and receipt of
Federal and State permits may be required to restore a higher level of public support for the
project. In fact, recognizing the risk of a negative re-zoning vote by Town Council, in late
November, Curis pulled its re-zoning application with the intent to re-submit post receipt of
permits. We see this as being a prudent decision since permitting approval by State and
Federal authorities should remove the onus on council to make a technical assessment on
the project – something Council is not qualified to do. Moreover, a stamp of approval by
government officials and planned participation in community meetings should provide
much-needed third-party input.
We see the potential for modest delays to the project start date and the likelihood of
additional monitoring by the ADEQ to satisfy community concerns on in-situ
leaching. The copper resource at Florence is hosted on both State and town lands, with anapproximate 50% / 50% split. Following the 2-2 Planning & Zoning Commission vote on the
re-zoning application (see our October 11, 2011 Curis research note), Curis expressed an
intent to start development on the State portion of the deposit while the Town land issue was
being resolved. The State and Federal agencies are expected to render permitting decisions
in early 2012. While development of the State lands does not require Town-level approval, we
view it as increasingly likely that the ADEQ and Curis may run the scaled-down test facility for
longer than would be expected otherwise to gather enough data to demonstrate that in-situ
leaching does not adversely effect the aquifer that sits above the copper resource. An
impermeable aquitard (clay layer) sits between the copper resource and aquifer. 10 years of
Page 3
aquifer water testing post completion of the BHP and Magna tests showed no signs of
contamination in the aquifer. We remain confident that the project will proceed but we have
pushed out our assumed start date as a result.
Financial Model
Incorporating more conservatism into our assumed timelines. In light of thedevelopments taking place in the Florence area described above, we see increased risks to
the assumed timelines. As mentioned, we see the potential for the ADEQ to call for a longer
period of water quality monitoring to satisfy community concerns. With this and an
approximate 3-month delay in receipt of the permits for the Phase 1 Production Test Facility
(PTF), we have incorporated a one-year delay to the start of full-scale production. We now
assume that work on the Phase I (PTF) starts in Q4/12 (vs. Q2/12 previously) and
commercial production starts in Q1/15 (vs. Q1/14 previously).
Financing assumptions also revised. At the same time, have pushed back the timing ofour equity and debt financing assumptions by two quarters. Concurrent with this we have
also assumed lower equity issue prices (we now assume the first equity raise of $30mln
takes place at $2.00 per share, down from $3.75 per share and the second equity raise of
$95mln takes place at $3.00 per share from $5.00 previously). To account for heightened
project risk, we have increased our assumed discount rate to 10% from 8%. We present our
new assumptions and the effect on our project and company valuation in Figure 1.
Next Steps
Near-term catalysts still in the hopper and should not be overlooked. 2011 deliveredvery few catalysts for Curis. 2012 should bring to bear an abundance of news flow much of
which has the potential to be transformational. Positive potential upcoming catalysts include:
(1) State permit approval, that could be in place in late Q1/12 or early Q2/12, (2) An off-take
deal that could include a component of project financing as well; and (3) New Town Council
members in Florence – scheduled for Spring of 2012, many new members are to be added to
the local Town Council. Assuming the new members are supportive of the project, this could
provide fresh support and minimize local opposition.
Page 4
Valuation
Lowering target price to $2.55 from $5.15; maintaining Outperform rating. Our target isbased on a 0.65x multiple (0.75x old) of our fully diluted, fully financed NAV10% (NAV8% old)estimate of $3.91/share ($6.78/sh old). We note, however, that a number of favourable
catalysts are in the lined up for H1/2012 that could cause us to revisit our assumptions with
an upward bias. We present our sensitivity analysis in Figure 2 below.
: