Incitec Pivot Ltd T.IPL

RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:Dear Wittman

[snewguy]

Great, if you cant stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.  Someone posted expect 10% capital return and divvy going forward.  I replied you havent seen that for the last 3 years, cuz thats the timeframe that the statement has been proven false.  Not out of a hat., its fact.  

Its not nonsense to say you havent seen any return in 3 years.  Its not nonsense to say the energy sector has sucked for 3 years since the downturn.  Whats your retort?  well, 20 years ago its been great?    well, great reply, go ahead and live in the past then!  lol.

Dont respond, but I will.    As for generating arguments to back ones points, no you cant on what I said.  You cannot change the fact that in reply to expect a 10 percent capital gain every year as the last 3 have proven, it did not happen.  And by the way, a paper loss is a loss because the value of that asset or your portfolio or your net worth is what it is on current value.  Go ahead and dispute that, then go talk to a banker and ask him if you can present a net worth statement on expected values or hopeful value? As a paper gain is the same.  Its worth what it is current value whether you sell now or hope it goes up.  lol  I am still up big on IPL but that does not mean i cant admit its sucked for years.

gotta luv bullboards.