RE:BEAUTY of a short attack!!! Kudos to Muddy Waters!Thanks for that chart, puts things in perspective. Management compounded things by completely refuting Muddy Waters' claims instead of owning up to some of the real issues at the mine. Then, when they subsequently had to lower guidance, it fed the short narrative and made it seem like Muddy Waters understood the issues better than management. They should have come clean at the time, tried to put things in perspective. Share price would have fallen but probably not as much as it has. This may be a takeover candidate now, given the management credibility issue.