RE:RE:RE:Pointing out the obviousI personally decided to focus my commentary on the 40% insider portion of the bought deal as this tends to be more contentious. (i.e. a confidence issue). As far as the remaining 60% of the deal in treasury shares, yes, obviously they are dilutive by approx 4%. So earnings have to grow by > 4% to be accretive to EPS. Let's be honest, if you don't think, with all the leverage and growth runway AT has, that they aren't growings earnings by way more than this (and this doesn't include any additional ROI on what they decide to do with the funds, i.e. acquisition), then its best to sell your shares and move on. And this comment is in no way directed at any one individual, just a general comment in case you have not done your DD and were just in for the momentum trade. Good luck to all LONGS!