Down 4% I was wondering that as well, performance definitely seems to be lagging others however I just keep in mind that even though it is down today they still pulled 40k barrels out of the ground at a wti of 73+. Unless we have been sold a real bill of goods eventually that free cash flow will be returned to shareholders one way or another. The little I have seen of management (Mr.Schmidt) they appear to be as honest and forthright as a CEO reasonably can be. I couldn't find any analyst calling for TVE at $10 , seems quite a stretch.