We have previously reported that the unformulated, free ML18J03 used in this study has EC50 values ranging from 7 × 10−4 μM to 0.0434 μM in SK-MEL-28 melanoma cells, following broadband visible light excitation, with considerable inter-assay variability due to its propensity to aggregate [
10]. The liposomal and micellar formulations of ML18J03 from our previous study have EC
50 values of 98.1 × 10
−4 μM and 49.1 × 10
−4 μM, respectively, in SK-MEL-28 cells following broadband visible light excitation. Using related cyclometalated Ru(II) complexes, we previously reported EC
50 values ranging from 0.142 μM to 0.258 μM in SK-MEL-28 and HL60 cells following broadband visible light excitation [
20]. Using [Os(phen)2(IP-nT)]Cl
2 complexes related to ML18J03, with varying thiophene chain lengths (nT), we also reported EC
50 values following broadband visible light excitation ranging from 1 μM to 3 μM for Os-nT = 0 to 2, and 0.153 μM to 18 × 10
−6 μM for Os-3T and Os-4T, respectively [
8]. However, the low water solubility and extensive aggregation can be significant limitations for these compounds.
Our ruthenium-based photosensitizer (TLD1433) currently being evaluated in clinical trials exhibits an EC50 value of 1.9 × 10−4 μM in SK-MEL-28 [7]. Other clinically approved PSs, such as Verteporfin (Visudyne; Bausch + Lomb, Laval, Canada) and Porfimer Sodium (Photofrin; Pinnacle Biologics, Bannockburn, IL) exhibit EC
50 values of 0.61–1.21 µM and 4.5 µM, respectively [
21,
22]. To put the PDT efficacy of Mic-ML18J03 into perspective, a comparison with other reported micelles previously used for PDT can be made. C225-conjugated chlorin e6-loaded polymeric micelles have exhibited an EC
50 value of 0.173 μM in A431 cells [
23]. Furthermore, Protoporphyrin IX-lipid micelles exhibited an EC
50 value of 35.6 μM in HeLa cells [
24]. A folate-mediated and pH-responsive chidamide-bound micelle system encapsulating the PS pyropheophorbide-
a also exhibited an EC
50 value of 0.062 μM in A2780 cells [
25].
While direct comparisons of EC50 do not take into consideration the wavelength, fluence and irradiance of photoexcitation, it is still evident that ML18J03 is a highly potent PS that is active in hypoxia and in normoxia. Micellar formulation of ML18J03 also improves water solubility and offers a more robust PDT response with significantly lower inter-assay variability. As such, this study proceeds to explore the ability of micellar formulation to significantly enhance the in vivo luminescence imaging options for ML18J03.