ENB or TRP. Did you back the wrong horse?"Business Strategy & Outlook Stephen Ellis, Sector Strategist, 9 Nov 2022
TC Energy faces many of the same challenges as Canadian pipeline peer Enbridge but also offers important contrasts. Both firms offer a 5%-7% growth profile and a utilitylike 95%-98% of earnings that are highly regulated or contracted, with several years of project backlog, despite Enbridge largely focusing on oil assets, while TC’s focus is natural gas. However, we also anticipate that any major new pipeline project for either firm will face substantial stakeholder challenges from a legal, regulatory, or community perspective, raising the risks and costs. The most critical differences between Enbridge and TC Energy arise from their approaches to energy transition, though TC Energy has made good progress here in 2022. Canadian carbon emissions taxes are expected to increase to CAD 170 a ton by 2030 from CAD 40 today, meaning it is critical that TC Energy, with its natural gas exposure, follow Enbridge’s approach to rapidly reduce its carbon emission profile and continue to pursue projects like the Alberta Carbon Grid, which will be able to transport more than 20 million tons of carbon dioxide. These taxes potentially increase costs for Canadian pipes compared with U.S. pipes but also make hydrogen a viable alternative to gas-powered electricity generation by 2030 in Canada, presenting an emerging threat. TC Energy recently introduced targets to reduce its Scope 1 and 2 intensity by 30% by 2030 and reach net zero by 2050, which is a start. In addition, Enbridge’s backlog is more diversified across its businesses already, and it already has a more material renewables business, including hydrogen, renewable natural gas, and wind efforts. While we think the renewables business lacks an economic moat today, we think it is an important area of investment for TC Energy that it needs to pursue. The renewables investments can compete for capital across the rest of the portfolio, generating reasonable returns on capital, allowing the overall enterprise to adapt to the markets as they evolve. As a result, we expect TC Energy's Bruce Power business to be a critical area of investment going forward."
TRP is a quality company and I have no doubt that it will bounce back from it's recent share price dips when CGL is finished and cash flows return and outlays decrease. It is probably a bargain here yielding over 7.5%. But where would I rather have my money right now?
Oh yeah, Go Enbridge! ;-)