Post by
mdjbrown on Jul 05, 2024 6:21pm
With all the experts on CBC explaining the magnitude of the
slide, not one of them has acknowledged the dozer sitting in the HLP. Why is that?
Instead they are pointing out rotational shear, overhangs, etc.
There is no reason a dozer should ever be in the HLP, so it is beyond rational thought why these so called experts have not referred to this unusual anomoly.
Before they conclusively offer any expert opinion to the masses, they better understand how this event unfolded.
As HB77 has mentioned, the 5 Ws are critically important before sharing expert opinion on anything, otherwise you are a talking head, which there are far too many of those on the news..
The other question that will eventually come to light, is how they get this $ million dollar plus piece of equipment out of the bowl without causing a secondary slide.
Big decisions ahead.
Comment by
HoneyBadger77 on Jul 05, 2024 6:41pm
Nincompoop, you really are from the UK aren't you? Stubborn as h_ell. Go to the Technical Report and figure it out for yourself. Yes, that will take a little time and work but come on now...You can do it! Or we can just keep going back and forth like this, annoying all the other board members. I'd rather not. HB77
Comment by
mdjbrown on Jul 05, 2024 6:46pm
nincompoop, have you ever watched a snowmobile start an avalanche taking down several snow packs with it. FYI, the HPL consists of loose material, not packed as you suggest. HB77 has attached both the Technical Report and HLP specs, so its all there. Just have to review it.
Comment by
nincompoop on Jul 05, 2024 7:05pm
If you happen to be walking along a pavement.... that's the proper name for a sidewalk by the way...and an earthquake starts...let me assure you...it wasn't you who started it.
Comment by
Zibo510 on Jul 05, 2024 7:11pm
My unqualified guess is that A The pad was stacked to high B The pad was stacked to steep, to severe an angle top to bottom on the sides. C Settlement of the base.
Comment by
nincompoop on Jul 05, 2024 7:21pm
I could go with settlement being some sort of trigger event but nothing regarding just surface movement. Dave Petley does know his stuff regarding the mechanics of rotational collapses, but this does not seem to relate to anything regarding surface events.
Comment by
nincompoop on Jul 05, 2024 7:27pm
I doubt in the entire history of dozers has one ever rolled, too wide, the natural inclination will always be to slide, go with the flow... I'm still in mourning on having a bunch of left wing commie morons being elected to be out next UK government, but apart from that I'll do my best to enjoy the weekend, hope you have a good one.