The time is ticking for the shareholders of NetSuite Inc (NYSE: N), as the final extended tender offer from Oracle Corporation (NYSE:
ORCL) to buy the company at $109 will expire Friday at
midnight EST.
The Beginning: July 2015
Late July, Oracle agreed to acquire
NetSuite, the “very first cloud company,” for about $9.3 billion. Oracle has been lagging in the cloud arena, which only accounted
10 percent of sales. Buying NetSuite, which became public in 2007, would help the software vendor to effectively compete against
salesforce.com, inc. (NYSE: CRM),
Microsoft Corporation (NASDAQ: MSFT) and
SAP SE (ADR) (NYSE: SAP).
Further, the connection between Oracle and NetSuite dates back to 1998, when Larry Ellison — current executive chairman of the
board and chief technology officer for Oracle — co-founded NetSuite along with Evan Goldberg in 1998. Regulatory filings show
Ellison and his family owning about 45.4 percent of NetSuite’s common stock.
The Roadblocks
But, the deal hit a roadblock
when T. Rowe Price, one of the largest shareholders of NetSuite, opposed the deal and asked for $133 price, which Oracle
refused.
According to terms of the Oracle agreement, a majority of NetSuite’s 40.8 million unaffiliated shares, or shares not tied to
Ellison and other insiders, must be tendered for the deal to be completed. As of July, T. Rowe Price owned 12.2 million NetSuite
shares. The other biggest shareholders include Capital World and Brown Advisory.
But, other than T. Rowe Price, none has publicly opposed the deal.
Original Tender Expiration To Now
As of October 6, the original tender expiration, 4.6 million unaffiliated shares were tendered, representing 11.2 percent of the
unaffiliated shares. If the required number of shares isn’t tendered, Oracle will withdraw its offer.
As such, the uncertainty over the deal has weighed on NetSuite shares, which have dropped about 18 percent since October 7 when
Oracle said $109 a share would be its final offer.
Also, the falling of NetSuite shares to $90 levels may indicate investors have given up on the deal.
If It Fails
But, the real
issue is the strong unlikelihood of any other bidder for NetSuite to arise should the Oracle takeover fall off, particularly
given the presence of Ellison as one of the largest shareholders of NetSuite.
But, Oracle has other
options even if it terminates NetSuite acquisition, as it may target The Ultimate Software Group, Inc.
(NASDAQ: ULTI), ServiceNow Inc (NYSE:
NOW) or Splunk Inc (NASDAQ: SPLK).
In fact, apart from the M&A speculation, Ultimate Software is likely to be the prime beneficiary in the event of the
potential collapse of the deal, as concerns of disruption to its NetSuite partnership ends.
If It Goes Through
If the deal happens, it would be Oracle’s second biggest acquisition after it bought PeopleSoft Inc. for $10.3
billion in 2005.
The cloud sector is seeing a lot of M&A in recent times, with salesforce spending more than $2.5 billion for
Demandware and Symantec Corporation (NASDAQ: SYMC)’s deal to buy Blue Coat Systems Inc. for $4.65 billion.
The Landmark Move
In May, Oracle itself announced a deal to buy Opower Inc., another cloud-services company, for $532 million.
But, the potential acquisition of NetSuite would be a landmark move for Oracle, only if it gets sufficient numbers of shares in its
favor.
At the time of writing, shares of Oracle were up 0.59 percent to $38.54 while NetSuite slipped 0.72 percent to $93.20. Thursday,
shares of NetSuite were halted after spiking to $94.60 on volume. It later resumed to close the session at $94.
Latest Ratings for ORCL
Date |
Firm |
Action |
From |
To |
Sep 2016 |
Macquarie |
Maintains |
|
Outperform |
Sep 2016 |
Nomura |
Maintains |
|
Buy |
Sep 2016 |
RBC Capital |
Maintains |
|
Outperform |
View More Analyst Ratings for
ORCL
View the Latest Analyst Ratings
© 2016 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.