RE:RE:Look at the volume traded on Penn West today SGY is overvalued and has a horrible balance sheet compared to Penn West. SGY eps -172.04 vs Penn West eps -3.89 SGY recent rating underperform Penn West rated outperform BNP isn't even good enough to trade on the NYSE....Penngrowth is a winner I have 1000 shares of PGF as well as Penn West. The company just sold it's Saskatchewan assets and paid down a big chunk of debt