RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:RE:A DUH moment for TinytotMac, I admit that I have no idea how the companies actually account for the transaction. Maybe they do it as you describe.
I am not an accountant by training, but from my business experience, I would have to say that a winning $10 bid would have been treated as a $10 cost, as simple as that. Everything else would follow.
Perhaps the companies account for it as you describe - but until they tell us that, I'll doubt it, and believe it is accounted for as I describe.
tinytot wrote: while I do not agree with your description below, I'll grant you that for all practical purposes we are saying the same thing
Macloud1 wrote: I think you are wrong Tiny If the winning bid is 10 dollars and MPVD won the bid then they have a cost of 5.10 and no sale at the moment. Debeers on the other hand have a sale of 5.10 and no additional cost .
If Debeers won the bid then they have a cost of 4.90 and no sale at the moment while MPVD in this case has a sale of 4.90 and no additional cost.
The winner has a cost at the onset and only knows if he is losing, breaking even or making a profit after the second sale. The loser on the other hand has a profit immediately after the first sale.