True North Commercial REIT T.TNT.UN

The "disposition effect"

[SIGG1]

The "disposition effect" is a well-documented behavioral bias in the field of behavioral finance. This phenomenon was first identified by Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman in their 1985 study. Here's a deeper look into the concept and its implications:

Understanding the Disposition Effect

1. Definition:

   • The disposition effect refers to the tendency of investors to sell assets that have increased in value (winners) while holding onto assets that have declined in value (losers). This behavior contradicts the rational investment strategy of cutting losses and letting profits run.

2. Psychological Basis:

   • Loss Aversion: Investors experience the pain of losses more intensely than the pleasure of gains. This asymmetry in emotional response drives them to avoid realizing losses.
   • Regret Avoidance: Selling a losing stock makes the loss concrete and forces the investor to confront the fact that they made a poor decision. By holding onto the stock, they can defer this regret, hoping the stock will eventually recover.
   • Mental Accounting: Investors tend to separate their investments into mental accounts. A realized loss feels like a failure, whereas an unrealized loss can be seen as just a temporary setback.

3. Consequences:

   • Poor Portfolio Performance: Holding onto losing stocks can lead to suboptimal portfolio performance as these stocks may continue to underperform.
   • Opportunity Cost: By not selling losers, investors miss out on the opportunity to reinvest the funds into potentially more profitable investments.
   • Tax Inefficiency: In some jurisdictions, realizing losses can provide tax benefits, such as offsetting gains. The disposition effect can lead to tax inefficiency by delaying loss realization.

Empirical Evidence

Research has consistently supported the presence of the disposition effect across different markets and investor types. For example, studies on individual investors, mutual funds, and even professional traders have shown similar tendencies.

Mitigating the Disposition Effect

Investors can adopt several strategies to counteract the disposition effect:

1. Pre-Set Rules: Establishing predetermined criteria for selling investments, such as stop-loss orders, can help remove emotional bias from decision-making.
2. Regular Portfolio Review: Periodic portfolio reviews with a focus on rebalancing can help investors make more rational decisions.
3. Education and Awareness: Understanding the disposition effect and its impact can help investors recognize and adjust their behavior.

Practical Implications

For financial advisors and portfolio managers, being aware of the disposition effect is crucial. They can help clients by:

1. Providing Objective Advice: Offering an outside perspective that is less influenced by emotional biases.
2. Creating Disciplined Investment Plans: Implementing systematic investment strategies that include regular rebalancing and clear sell criteria.
3. Encouraging Long-Term Focus: Emphasizing long-term investment goals over short-term performance can help mitigate the impact of the disposition effect.

Conclusion

The disposition effect is a significant behavioral bias that can negatively impact investment performance. By understanding its underlying causes and employing strategies to counteract it, investors can make more rational and effective investment decisions.