http://farm6.static.flickr.com/5003/5206104424_8f26fba5fd_b.jpg



Equities
_______



The Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada issued a plan Thursday to create single-stock automatic circuit breakers “to address rapid, significant and unexplained price movement … that calls into question whether there is a fair and orderly market for that security.”



______________________________________________________________________________________________



Single-stock circuit breaker eyed for Canada


JANET McFARLAND

From Friday's Globe and Mail




Canada’s stock market regulator is proposing a mechanism to temporarily halt trading in individual stocks after dramatic price movements.

The Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada issued a plan Thursday to create single-stock automatic circuit breakers “to address rapid, significant and unexplained price movement … that calls into question whether there is a fair and orderly market for that security.”

The plan is part of ongoing efforts by the industry to address concerns caused by the “flash crash” trading frenzy last spring.

While circuit breakers already exist for broader market movements, IIROC must manually review trading in an individual security and decide whether it should be halted.

In “flash crash” trading on May 6, however, this manual process could not keep up with rapid price drops in a number of securities.

“Current practice is not adequate where there is a need to halt trading in multiple securities across multiple marketplaces, all in a short window of time,” IIROC said in a statement.

IIROC launched a review of market controls this spring after North American stocks fell by hundreds of points within minutes on May 6, then swiftly reversed and recovered to finish almost unchanged by the end of the day. Regulators said uncontrolled price declines in a few securities spread to trigger a broader market selloff.

U.S. regulators introduced single-stock circuit breakers in June on a trial basis in response to the May trading.

IIROC’s similar new policy would see trading halted for five minutes for TSX-listed shares, with the possibility of an extension. Stocks listed on the TSX Venture Exchange and the CNSX exchange would be halted for 10 minutes because of lower trading liquidity on those exchanges.

TSX-listed stocks would be halted when the stock price rises or falls by at least 10 per cent, or 10 trading increments, whichever is greater, within five minutes. Stocks listed on the TSX Venture or CNSX would be halted after movements of at least 20 per cent, or 20 trading increments, over 10 minutes.

A trading increment is one cent on stocks trading at more than 50 cents per share, and half a cent for those of 50 cents or less.

The proposed circuit breakers would be in effect in Canadian markets from 9:50 a.m. to 3:40 p.m., which means they would not be in place for 20 minutes at the opening and closing of trading.

IIROC said the new mechanism would be part of a “multi-tiered” approach for controlling short-term price volatility that includes the existing obligations of securities firms to supervise trading, and “effective marketplace volatility controls” across exchanges.

“The single-stock circuit breaker would represent the third level of controls,” IIROC said.

The regulator has asked for public comment on the proposal until Jan. 17.




____________________________________________________________


Comments

matt s

6:01 PM on November 18, 2010

How annoying it would be to be unloading a sizable position, trying to beat the herd, when you are all of a sudden stopped. And when trading resumes, the herd has caught up and you lose a butt-load trying to off the rest of your position....not very happy....



___________________________

Abraxas

5:52 PM on November 18, 2010

"unexplained price movement"....How are they going to keep on top of the news and move instantaneously on what is explained and unexplained ? This kind of threatens "due diligence"and impedes the quick and nimble investors. Nice intentions but I can see problems arising out of it. Add another thousand bureaucrats to the mix. All the online trading services warn sellers and I assume buyers,that they are about to make a drastically different price move than current bids or asks. That should stop the manual fat fingers. Perhaps they ought to just legislate the auto traders to have the same alert on autotrading. An alert that would require human notice and intervention to bypass/go ahead, when it happens.



___________________________

matt s

4:57 PM on November 18, 2010

If you are going to limit movements during the day, you also have to ban any kind of information being released during trading hours. No earnings reports, no economic information, no FOMC announcements at 2:15pm, etc. And I would be inclined to set your on times to between 10am and 3:30pm. Stocks can run up and then run straight back down quite quickly first thing in the morning...


___________________________

Root C

5:35 PM on November 18, 2010

Controls should be placed where there is none... on derivatives

___________________________

Cabo

7:31 PM on November 18, 2010

Lets start by dealing with flash trading first before they start screwing investors looking for liquidity. IIROC is a hopeless bunch, almost as useless as the TMX.

__________________________

whazzup

4:00 PM on November 18, 2010

Good, this has shown to work and did during the last fat finger episode. The break can last 15 seconds, thats enough to sort out whats what.

__________________________

Jteeth

5:29 PM on November 18, 2010

The securities industry will always be a fraudulent industry until its fumigated. That means getting rid of all the miscreants and complicit media.

Janet you have ZERO credibility.


________________________________________________________________________________________________




Thanks for checking out my page. Red Mars



http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2380/4509010151_5eab9cf8ee_b.jpg